Madinat al-Muslimeen Islamic Message Board
| Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| Anonymous |
| 03/04/01 at 8:36:36 PM |
| Does anyone know of the proper greetings for Eid ul Adha? Perhaps 3 or 4 might help. Shukran. |
| Re: Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| meraj |
| 03/04/01 at 9:39:10 PM |
| slm, well according to the brother who teaches our sunday school class, he said that saying 'Eid Mubarrak' is bidd'ah. the best thing to say is 'Takabalallahu minna wa minkum'... i forget the exact meaning of it, but it means something like 'may Allah accept (the prayers) from me and from you'. i have also heard others say 'Eid Saeed'... so umm... anyway, takabalallahu minna wa minkum :) |
| Re: Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| PacificBreeze |
| 03/04/01 at 11:42:06 PM |
| one grammatical point: taqabballah minNA wa minkum may Allah accept from US and from you taqaballah minni wa minkum ditto except from me and from you |
| WHAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|---|
| princess |
| 03/05/01 at 01:46:03 |
| [quote]well according to the brother who teaches our sunday school class, he said that saying 'Eid Mubarrak' is bidd'ah. [/quote] walikumas'salaam warahmatullah :) what? what? what? ??? has arsalAN read this? ;) how in the world is that bid'ah? plz..someone explain..:) thanks :) ma'salaam ;-D |
| Re: Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| meraj |
| 03/05/01 at 08:33:28 |
| slm, [quote]one grammatical point: taqabballah minNA wa minkum may Allah accept from US and from you[/quote] thanx pacbreez... i knew i had something wrong there ;-D haha no arsalAN didnt say that... the brother who said it didnt explain... he just said that it was an innovation and its better to say 'takaballah...' after the eid khutba instead of eid mubarrak... he was reading it out of a book... inshallah i'll ask him about it today :) |
| Re: Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| bhaloo |
| 03/05/01 at 12:08:11 |
| slm I hadn't heard that saying Eid Mubarak was biddah, in fact the sheikh explaining how to do the Eid prayer said Eid Mubarak after that. |
| Re: Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| widad |
| 03/05/01 at 16:14:17 |
| Well,here we say : "takabal Allah minna wa minkum salih al-a'amal" (the last two words mean : good deeds). we also say: "min ala'aydeen,alfayzeen" meaning : hoping you are from the ones who return(a'aydeen)and winners(fayzeen). Of course in my homepage I did use "eid mubarak" because it the one understood universally. |
| NS |
| Re: Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| PacificBreeze |
| 03/06/01 at 02:30:23 |
| Eid Mubaaarrriiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiikkkkkkkkkkkk!!! :) |
| Re: Eid ul Adha |
|---|
| Anonymous |
| 03/07/01 at 14:47:02 |
| AS salaamu alaykum, and may Allah accept all of you all good deeds and mines. Subhanallah, this morning i was reading ibn Taymiyyahs'Fatawa and i happened to come across a question similar to the original one, whereby he {ibn Taymiyyah} was asked: "does the greeting which many people say at the time of eid "Eid Mubarak" or what is similar to this, is there a basis or not for this in the shareeah, and there is a basis for this in the shareeah, how do we reply? The answer: As for the greeting on the day of eid they used to say to each other after the eid salah "taqabal Allah mina wa minka", "ahaalullaha alayka", or what is similar to this. And this is what has been narrated that the sahabahs used to do, and other scholars such as imam Ahmad saw it as permissible. However, imam Ahmad said "I do not initiate {the greeting} with anyone, but if someone says it to me, I answer him greeting back". And this is because returning a greeting is wajib, but as for initiating the greetings, then this is not a sunnah one is commanded to do, nor is one also prohibited from doing it, thus whoever does it he is following a good example and whoever leaves it off is also following a good example, and Allah knows best. Btw, this is from Assing, my computer is down, hence i am posting in this manner. |
Individual posts do not necessarily reflect the views of Jannah.org, Islam, or all Muslims. All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners. Comments are owned by the poster and may not be used without consent of the author.The rest © Jannah.Org |