Madinat al-Muslimeen Islamic Message Board

A R C H I V E S

why  do you  smoke ?

Madina Archives


Madinat al-Muslimeen Islamic Message Board

why  do you  smoke ?
sal
06/17/03 at 18:09:08
[slm]
It  is not shame to confess  smoking ,but can  any  one who smokes  tell  me why  he/she smokes ? dont  be  embarassed  ... just say  it  , may  be we can  find  a way to  stop  it  if  you are willing  so  .
[]



06/17/03 at 18:10:00
sal
Re: why  do you  smoke ?
Emerald
06/21/03 at 23:01:51
Well from what I know is that if one commits a sin, he/ she must not broadcast it because it would almost be like stating you're not ashamed of it. So if you do smoke, you should be ashamed because it is a sin.

I know it's probably controversial because some think it's not. The way I see it though is that Allah (swt) entrusted you with one of His greatest creations and therefore one should take great care of it instead of slowly polluting and killing it. In the end it will return to its rightful owner/Creator- Allah (swt). Our bodies just don't belong to us.

I also think it's quite obvious why some people do it. Either for the "glamour" of it, as a release from social pressures, or just simply because they're addicted. In any case, it's no excuse.
Re: why  do you  smoke ?
sal
06/22/03 at 06:52:35
[slm]
Emerald   said  
[quote]   Well from what I know is that if one commits a sin, he/ she must not broadcast it because it would almost be like stating you're not ashamed of it. So if you do smoke, you should be ashamed because it is a sin.   [/quote]And this  is  actually  what  I wanted  to   submit  .that  smoking  is HARAM .  
Not  to  be  taken  as simple  as some smokers deceive  themselves  by  saying  it  is  MAKRUH ( DISLIKED) as an  excuse  that  this  is  not  a  big  sin  
May  be  it  is  not  a  big  sin  but  the word  disliked  ..disliked  by  who ? this  is  a  question  we  need  to  stop  at  . well  the  answer  is  disliked  by  ALLAH
So  doing  some  thing  disliked  by  ALLAH ? what  can we call  this  ? not  HARAM?  
Well  When we are  asked a  simple  question  and  fail  to  answer  .
I  know  nobody  has  a  logic  answer  
To  say why  he/she  smokes  ..so  this might  drive  him/her  to  give up   smoking  . INSHALLAH  
;-)
06/22/03 at 06:54:22
sal


Madinat al-Muslimeen Islamic Message Board
A R C H I V E S

Individual posts do not necessarily reflect the views of Jannah.org, Islam, or all Muslims. All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners. Comments are owned by the poster and may not be used without consent of the author.
The rest © Jannah.Org